 |
|
Neil Mortine
CEO,
Fahlgren Mortine Public
Relations and
Fahlgren Advertising |
Let's face it: The days of having a sole "brand
manager" are changing. In the trenches, it's about making sure the entire team is armed with
clear standards, solid strategy and good judgment to act as brand stewards—regardless of
whether you come from the PR or advertising side, says Neil Mortine. He
should know. He is CEO of both Fahlgren Mortine Public Relations and Fahlgren
Advertising, and certainly is in a unique position to provide some perspective on integrating
the two disciplines.
What's more, continues Mortine, "With the rise of social media, mobile marketing and more,
there is often little delineation between public relations and advertising—and there's no
universal rulebook that declares which discipline owns what turf," he says.
The upshot: The future of our industry lies in working together better—that true "integration"
is what clients expect now. So how do you do that? What best practices can you learn from
other council members who are making it work? Read on for the answers and tips into being
a better team player:
1. Adopt a discipline-neutral approach. "In today's media-saturated world,
there are dozens of strategic ways to reach the same consumer, so we have to challenge ourselves—and
our clients—to be open minded and flexible in determining the truly best solution," says
Mortine. "Agency account leads can exhibit a bias toward their own discipline. So, it's important
to have an open forum among the client and our partners to openly discuss discipline-neutral
solutions. Nobody wants to be considered an add-on to a program once the strategy has been
set," he stresses.
The solution: "Take a discipline-neutral approach to solving our clients'
problems. We have to start by asking, 'What is the client problem we're really trying to
solve?' At the day-to-day program management level, we have to push for regular all-agency
meetings when all partners sit together at the table to discuss plans, poke holes in strategy,
challenge tactics and share information. These could be regular weekly conference calls or
quarterly 'Agency Summits.' Whatever the format, it's important to be all together on a regular
basis."
 |
|
Lisa Sepulveda
Weber Shandwick |
 |
|
Bob Pearson
Chief Technology
and Media Officer
WeissComm Group |
Weber Shandwick's Lisa Sepulveda,
who is responsible for the sharing of best practices and coordinating global
brands across the network, agrees: "Check your channel and your ego at the door," she says,
and illustrates with this example: "I worked on the Dove campaign and Unilever
pulled together all their marketing partners for planning. The charge wasn't to think 'PR,
advertising and marketing.' Instead, we were given permission to think of it from a channel
agnostic front. Once the big idea was arrived at, we were asked to think
of the particulars of our respective channels and disciplines—but that should never be the
starting point."
2. Know the client's business better than other partners. "Agencies
often know their area of expertise—but not the client's business," says Bob Pearson,
chief technology and media officer at WeissComm Group. As the former communities
and conversations director at Dell, he has seen it from both the agency and client side.
His advice: "There can often be disconnects from agency partners, including advertising,
about the company's business model. You can stand out by avoiding the usual agency politics
and instead zeroing in on one key area of the client's business that nobody else will have
cornered. For example, know more than anybody else at the table about your client's customers'
online behaviors. Bring data and research to the table around that—pegged to the opportunities
for the business that come out of it.
His point: "Know more than is expected about that brand. Show that you're already 'living
the business.' That positions you as a partner and not just a vendor."
Pearson offers these additional tips:
- Avoid agency politics—don't complain about other partners. "As a client,
if an agency complains about other agencies—I see an agency with problem. I don't see their
story as being true. They're just a pain in the ass."
- Share materials without fear. "I have seen agencies scared to send materials
and client slides to each other," says Pearson. "If a CMO sees you being reluctant to share
'proprietary' material with their other agencies, that's a chink in the armor that will
mean the executive won't have a problem letting you go when it comes time to renew."
 |
|
Doug Spong
President
Carmichael
Lynch Spong
|
3. Consider a "Low Hedge Row" model. Doug
Spong, president of Carmichael Lynch Spong, agrees—and puts forth
what he calls a "Low Hedgerow" philosophy: "You have to think holistically about a client's
business these days—or get marginalized and left in the dust. I am president on the PR
side here, and also took over as president of Carmichael Lynch Advertising, it's rare to
find a firm without some level of integration." His point: "Think beyond just your PR borders."
Do that by thinking of the best neighbors, he advises: "They are separated by a low hedge
row. A hedge row defines property lines, but it's a low one separating your area of expertise
from theirs. It's low because you can look into their yard, see what's going on, introduce
yourself across it, climb or go around the hedge row with respect, ask for help or even offer
help. The metaphor works so well in integration for clients. Everybody brings certain gifts
and talents. For PR, it's usually overall reputation management, media relations and social
media skills."
4. Follow the money—and the new "Golden Rule." "The real 'Golden Rule'
is that 'He who has the gold, rules,'" says Spong. "Most advertising budgets are 10-20 times
the size of a typical PR budget. As such, ad agencies often view themselves as the brand
steward, and clients tend to defer to ad agencies first—from perspectives of consumer insight,
positioning, core strategies, media strategies and even timing of programs and campaigns.
So the big challenge for PR firms is to assert their voice at the table to follow that money
and be a part of the program."
Ways to do that:
- Speak the same language. "Get out of your PR speak," advises Spong.
"Instead of saying 'reputation management' with the client, talk about 'brand strategy.'
Instead of just talking about 'key messages,' understand based on consumer insight, the
core brand position and brand idea that will come out of that and how it will be executed."
- Think strategy, not tactics. "Instead of thinking tactically about things
like, 'Hey, let's have a Tweetup,' or 'Let's host a special event,' or 'Let's get a big
hit in The Wall Street Journal'—think broader. Focus on strategy and holistic
program goals, not PR outputs."
- Keep friends close and enemies closer. "If ad agencies control budget
and strategy—then pull them in as close as you can by asking for insight and research,
all consumer data and so on. Have a download of the big brand idea from their research
and planning teams. Ask to sit with their media and consumer engagement people to look
at media segmentation and targeting information and research. Pull them close and leverage
their assets. Out of that will come the ultimate benefit to the client—synergy in terms
of strategy, having one brand position and ideas executed across multiple platforms. If
you are part of that synergy, you will be in great shape with the client."
5. Push for open access. Mortine elaborates on that point: "Communication
with other agency partners doesn't always need to funnel through the client (or an ad or
PR account lead) as a clearinghouse," he says. "At Fahlgren, we function as one team so we
share ideas, feedback and input in all directions. This way, meetings are reserved for active
planning and we show up ready to work together, not just report. But collaborative reporting
among inside and outside teams is also helpful. In some cases, we have created an open status
report housed on a secure website that can be accessed by all agency partners."
Spong adds these quick tips:
- Offer the first olive branch. "Open the door to mutual access by taking
the first step," he advises. "Set up a principal to principal meeting as soon as you're
working on the account. Pick up the phone and offer the first olive branch."
- Get onsite soon. "Go to their facility and make it easy for them to
share and download," he suggests. "And do it on your dime if it requires travel. Set up
a day-long download with their account planning staff. Meet with the creative director
and have them show how they're executing against research tied to the company's positioning.
That's also a good time to ask about the unique requirements or challenges of working with
that client."
Sepulveda adds this: "Build a relationship," she counsels. "Do that by getting to know people
face to face—email and texting doesn't do this. Get out from behind your desk and spend real
time with the client's agency partners. You develop a trust that way."
- Align metrics. "Meet with their analytics people to talk about how you're
going to measure success together and what you need to build into your program to align
with their metrics," advises Spong.
6. Work from one strategic plan. "Often, respective disciplines develop
their own plans, and then start implementing without putting the pieces back together strategically
to look for synergies," relates Mortine.
Here's an example of how having one plan makes a collective campaign stronger: "One of our
clients is a state tourism division, and our campaign is all about attracting visitors from
key feeder markets in contiguous states. Each year, when various plans are completed for
PR, advertising, digital/mobile and publications (all separate agencies), we put our timelines
back together and look for gaps. If our budget can't support print and online advertising
in one of those markets during the peak travel-planning season, we'll plan a media relations
blitz, grassroots event or targeted social media program there to drive awareness and/or
message frequency."
7. Forget about turf and focus on good ideas. "We actually like the healthy
competition that comes from working alongside other agency disciplines. But you have to forget
about 'turf' and 'ownership' and just focus on good ideas," advises Mortine. "Experience
has shown us that no client will shoot down an idea because it's out of bounds. If it's
a smart, on-strategy approach that's doable within budget, you just find a way to make it
work and the whole team gets to celebrate in the end."
8. Be interested in what the other partners are doing. "Ask to see the
creative they produce," Mortine suggests. "Great PR ideas can result from advertising campaigns.
For example, Fahlgren Advertising launched a campaign focused on communicating the medical
innovations of a regional healthcare system. When Fahlgren Mortine was tasked with rolling
out the program internally to hospital associates, we took the idea of innovation to a different
level, showcasing how any associate—medical or administrative—can be innovative. Both the
external and internal campaigns were a huge success due largely in part to the strong collaboration
between the two disciplines."
9. Educate partners about what PR brings to the table. "We never want to
assume roles based upon discipline. The disciplines are definitely blurring at the edges,
but remain pure at their core. For example, walking through the mystery of what goes into
an excellent thought leadership program can help advertising partners as well as clients
see the value of third party credibility and strategic messaging that support larger brand
positioning efforts," says Mortine.
His point: "As PR pros, we need to help our peers in other communications disciplines overcome
the perception that all we do is media relations or publicity. We need to effectively demonstrate
what our discipline is all about, bring forth new ideas, share results and help other partners
understand the full scope of what PR brings to the table."
10. Tap client partners' resources. "Each discipline can learn much from
each other. PR can apply the multitude of strategic consumer insights that can be gained
from advertising's media resources, for example, in order to provide better counsel and programs,"
Mortine says. "And advertising professionals are seeing that as the ad industry re-invents
itself in a self-selecting, consumer-controlled media world, public relations strategies
play an even more important role in shaping brand perceptions and experience. You can wear
yourself out trying to find the philosophical right answers, but at the end of the day, it's
about making it work."
Spong reiterates his earlier point: "Advertising agencies bring a level of consumer insight
that most PR principals aren't even aware of, let alone understand. It's in your best interests
to tap that, research it, study it and incorporate it into your own efforts." But that can't
happen, he warns, if you've "burned bridges or come at the client work from a silo mindset." |