By Lynn Casey, Chair & CEO, Padilla Speer
Beardsley
My firm is employee owned, the result of its former leaders' interest in remaining
independent and its current leaders' disinterest in taking on large amounts
of debt to purchase the firm.
We created our Employee Stock Ownership Plan in 1993. For the next eight years,
the company contributed the equivalent of nearly 15 percent of employee salaries
to the ESOP trust. As a result, we were able to retire our previous leadership
debt free.
The ESOP addressed our financial succession. It also delivered another important
benefit: Differentiation. Our employee-owned structure became a point of distinction
at a critical period in our growth. We were beginning to reach beyond our legacy
Midwest corporate and investor-relations practices and to compete nationally
with firms that were more established in B2B and B2C marketing territory. Workplace
differentiation was paramount to recruiting and retaining talent and clients.
Given that, you might expect the rest of this piece to lobby, wholesale, on
behalf of ESOPs. Not so. Creating and operating an employee-owned structure
isn't for everyone. It requires a high level of financial discipline. It carries
an administrative cost. And it demands gut-level discussions about the timing
of major shareholder departures and retirements in order to minimize repurchase
liability.
An employee-ownership structure isn't for everyone. However, the ESOP experience
has convinced me that an employee-ownership culture IS for everyone.
Although an Employee Stock Ownership Plan may be the most direct route to creating
that culture, there are many ways to foster an ownership mentality.
I can testify to that last point first-hand, since Padilla's employee-ownership
culture was established long before we created the ESOP. Scan the grid below
and you'll see that the Rights and Responsibilities that guide our ESOP are
not exclusive to a type of structure – only to a type of mindset. And when
that mindset happens, however it happens, everybody wins.
Open Books and Open Minds
Many public relations firms have some level of open-book management. Our view
is the more you help employees understand the business, the more likely they
are to enter their time, get invoices out the door, and think twice before
they expand the scope of work without prior client approval. Review financial
statements at monthly staff meetings, and everyone will understand how a consulting
firm makes money, where that money goes, and how they can help keep more of
it within the company.
All-Out Sharing
Making more money for the company begs the question of who benefits from the
additional income. Before we became an ESOP, we gave year-end bonuses to every
employee. The bonus pool was based on income; the bonuses checks were based
on individual performance. After we become an ESOP, we chose to continue performance-based
bonuses in addition to ESOP contributions, since the latter cannot account
for individual performance. If your company doesn't make performance bonuses
available to all employees, reconsider this if at all possible. It's not just
the money. It's a show of respect and an acknowledgement that everyone who
plays a part in the firm's success should benefit from the firm's success.
Ideas from Anywhere
On our Intranet is an employee-generated "Top Ten" list in support of an ESOP
(read: employee-ownership) culture. Reason Four says "It's great to be an employee
owner at Padilla because we can voice our opinions about all aspects of the
company with freedom." That mindset is not exclusive to an ESOP any more than
a good idea is the sole domain of senior management. Of course, we must temper
these "ideas from anywhere" with the insight that's available only to those
who lead the company. But top down is dead, if it ever lived at all in successful
professional-service firms. An employee- ownership culture fosters more ideas
-- and more good ideas -- in addition to loyalty and pride.
Shared Solutions
Some firms survey staff on their level of engagement. Many don't. They fear
the answers will create an "us vs. them" attitude between managers and staff.
In an ownership culture, that's less likely to happen. Problems – and their
solutions -- are a shared responsibility. If employees share in the rewards,
they also must share in surfacing issues and finding answers.
An employee-ownership structure helped my firm define its point of difference.
I'm grateful for that. I'm even more enthused that the ownership culture behind
an ESOP is available to all public relations firms regardless of structure.
If you're not already there, I encourage you to embrace the culture of employee
ownership and make it your own. Rights & Responsibilities of Employee Ownership
Rights |
Responsibilities |
To share in finacial success of the company.
|
To contribute to the finacial success of the company.
|
To vote on issues affecting the company as defined in the
ESOP plan.
|
To exercise your right to vote and to do so based on careful
considerartion of the facts at hand.
|
To be well informed about the management and
strategic direction of the company.
|
To accept and support management decisions and initiatives.
|
| To question business practices that you do not believe are
in the company's best interests. |
To help find solutions and not just point out problems. |
| To have access to the information that illustrates how your
actions and decisions affect company profitibility. |
To evaluate your actions and decisions from an ownership
perspective. |
Lynn Casey is the, chair and CEO of Minneapolis, MN-based Padilla Speer
Beardsley. She is also a founding partner of the Worldcom Public Relations
Group. |